tpm t h e p h i l o s o p h e r s ’ m a g a z i n e Issue 51 • 1st quarter 2011

Contents …

ACTIONS & EVENTS

4 5 12 13 15 19

From the editor News Language, Spooks and Logic

Mediawatch Philosophy and philosophers in the mass media

Threads Rage against the experience machine

Philosophers in power Can they change politics?

Word of Mouse Computers that feel your pain

THOUGHTS

21 31 34 43

The Interview Martha Nussbaum fights for the liberal arts

Sci-Phi Do societies evolve?

TPM Essay Simon Blackburn on philosophy’s wrong turns

Wiping the slate clean Eve Garrard and David McNaughton on forgiveness

43

49 55

Letter from… Juraj Hvorecky in Prague

The psychology of happiness It’s not an exact science, say Aaron Jarden and Dan Weijers

FORUM

60

Philosophical intuitions Stephen Stich and Wesley Buckwalter present an x-phi parable

60

66 72

78

87

Is morality relative? Joshua Knobe asks the folk

Intending harm Mark Phelan has virtually no adverse side-effects

There’s nothing it’s l ike to see red Edouard Machery and Justin Sytsma on pains and perceptions

What’s the point of x-phi? David Papineau has doubts

89

Just make it stop Tamler Sommers demands an end to the x-phi debate

■ tpm 1ST QUARTER 2011