>> CONTENTS November 2005

Issue No 291

COVER Roderick Buchanan History Painting 2004 detail

01 FEATURES

The Invisible Curator Curators are at their best when they put artists before ideas says Craig Burnett 07 The Co-dependent

Curator Paul O’Neill on the dysfunctional relationship between independent curators and institutions

14 COMMENT

EDITORIAL LETTERS

15 NEWS

ARTNOTES

18 REVIEWS

EXHIBITIONS Istanbul Biennale 9 Iwona Blazwick 20 British Art Show 6

Sarah James 21 Lyons Biennale 2005

Pryle Behrman 24 Rita Donagh

Cherry Smyth 24 Jaki Irvine

Maria Walsh 26 George Brecht

Anna Dezeuze 27 Francis Alÿs

Pablo Lafuente 28 Roderick Buchanan

Gilda Williams 29 Ways of Living

Marcus Verhagen 31 Campus

Martin Herbert 33 Letter from New York

Sally O’Reilly 36 BOOKS

On Criticism Kathy Battista

36 Video Art

Felicity Sparrow 38 NET WORKS

Soft Cinema Michael Gibbs

39 RESPONSE

On Skill Matthew Collings

40 POLEMIC

Cities of Culture Dany Louise

41 ARTLAW

Ways of Working Henry Lydiate

42 LISTINGS

EXHIBITIONS

Art Monthly 4th Floor 28 Charing Cross Road London WC2H 0DB United Kingdom

Telephone 020 7240 0389 Advertising 020 7240 0418 Fax 020 7497 0726 info@artmonthly.co.uk www.artmonthly.co.uk

ISSN 0142 6702 Art Monthly is published 10 times a year

Editor Patricia Bickers Managing Editor Letty Mooring Deputy Editor Andrew Wilson Editorial Assistant Frederika Whitehead Listings Chris McCormack listings@artmonthly.co.uk Advertising Matt Hale Chris McCormack ads@artmonthly.co.uk Subscriptions Brendan Fan subs@artmonthly.co.uk Distribution Brendan Fan dist@artmonthly.co.uk Publisher Jack Wendler Design Area

1 1

0

2 5 2 7 4 8 1 2 6 6

7

Published by Britannia Art Publications Ltd. All editorial, advertising and subscription enquiries to Art Monthly 4th Floor, 28 Charing Cross Road, London WC2H 0DB, T 020 7240 0389, F 020 7497 0726, info@artmonthly.co.uk. Printed in Great Britain by Brown Knight & Truscott, North Farm Road, Tunbridge Wells, Kent TN2 3BW. Bookshop/Gallery Retail Distribution: Central Books Ltd, 99 Wallis Rd, London E9 5LN, T 020 8986 4854, F 020 8533 5821, E orders@centralbooks.com; Newstrade Distribution: Comag Specialist Division, Tavistock Works, Tavistock Road, West Drayton, Middx UB7 7QX, T 01895 433 800, F 01895 433 801, E andy.hounslow@comag.co.uk; USA: Ubiquity Distributors, 607 Degraw Street, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA, T 718 875 5491, E info@ubiquitymags.com. The views expressed in Art Monthly are not necessarily those of the Publishers or Editors. Articles submitted for possible publication and accompanied by SAE are welcomed, but it is advisable to contact the Editorial Department beforehand. While every effort will be made to safeguard unsolicited mss, photos and other material submitted, the Editors will not accept responsibility for loss or damage. Art Monthly is available on audio tape for the visually impaired from TNAUK, T 01435 866102. The electronic version of Art Monthly is available on the Art Index http://www.hwwilson.com. © No part of this publication may be reprinted or otherwise reproduced in any way without permission. Art Monthly has been set in Art Monthly Sans and Art Monthly Serif.