Mad scenes over Sutherland's Lucia 6 REVIEWS

EDITOR'S CHOICE

The best new recordings of the month

SOUNDBITES

8 ORCHESTRAL

Barenboim and Vanska are noble and shocking in Beethoven's Ninth; Ilan Volkov reveals Roslavets

FOR THE RECORD

10 FILM MUSIC

Eschenbach steps down in Philadelphia ; ENil signs Kate Royal and Nina Stemme A lavish Chinese version of Hamlet

CHAMBER

ENCOUNTERS Conductor Kristjan Jarvi on his confrontation with Vienna

14 Perfect programming from Queyras

ONE TO WATCH Dutch pianist Ralph van Raat DIARY Simon Keenlyside, singing farmer INTERVIEW Sharon Bezaly's golden flute HARRIET SMITH Cult stars - forget the music, it's all about the underwear PHIUP KENNICOTT

17

19

21

23

24

The music of Hollywood - commercial, yes, but so often trashy as well THAT STRAIN AGAIN 26 Opera is no stranger to censorship THE GRAMOPHONE DEBATE 28 Can downloading revitalise classical sales? TAKING NOTE 31 What the world's music press is writing BLOGWATCH 32 Baroque dissonance meets the FonzmusicaI musings of pianist Jeremy Denk USA (North American edition only) A1 How the Met's new manager Peter Gelb plans to attract new audiences ARMANDO IANNUCCI 35 Which came first - the words or music?

INSTRUMENTAL

Masterful playing from Paul Lewis VOCAL Paul McCreesh's vital Vespers OPERA A vivid archive Drm Carki from the ROH DVD Mark Elder's Gloriana is not to be missed MUSICAL THEATRE ON DVD African Bizet and Carnegie's SlYuth Pacifo: REPLAY Unleashing the elements in Bruckner SPOKEN WORD Olivier and Edith Evans from EMl BOOKS Stravinsky exiled and Cage conversations

SOUNDWAVES TV AND RADIO Tilson Thomas's televised teachings TUNE SURFING The best Beethoven on the web

MUSICAL JOURNEYS SEEN AND HEARD It's business as usual for the Israel Phil WHAT'S ON 141 The best events from around the world

FEATURES COVER STORY Beethoven's visionary symphonies speak urgently to our time LA STUPENDA AT 80 Celebrating the art of Dame Joan

THE COLLECTION

36

HIG H-FIDELITY AUDIO AND VISUAL Apple's iPod player can fiji a room

44

FINALE MY MUSIC

50 RSC artistic director Michael Boyd

The Seventh Symphony ofJean Sibelius CRmcs' CHOICE S7 Gramophrme reviewers name the perfect stocking-fillers of the past year

SUBSCRIPTIONS CLASSIFIEDS NEW RELEASES REVIEWS INDEX

C O\fER ~ TL\I O'BRIEN CONTENTS : FROM TOP; BRIDGEMAN ART LIBRARY, N EIL COOP ER

o recyclewt-Iyow-...~ .......

r, j , 1'IOtIO'-"'"p ,-", ....ydoo www.gramophone.co.uk

GRAMOPHONE

GRAMOPHONE DECEMBER 2006 3